The Law Office of

David Cameron Carr

Ethics Lawyer

Experienced counsel and representation for lawyers on matters involving legal ethics and the law of lawyering.

State Bar Reinstatement

A: Attorneys often resign with charges pending for conduct that would not justify disbarment, simply because they do not want to fight and don't care to practice law anymore. Resignation is offered as an easy out. Surprisingly, or maybe not, many of them want to get back in after a few years...
U.S. Supreme Court Hallway

Reinstatement to practice after disbarment or resignation with charges pending has been an option for all California attorneys since before the State Bar Act in 1927. Reinstatement is a difficult, expensive and time consuming process for many attorneys; while many reinstatement petitions are successful, many are a waste of resources before the necessary planning and preparation for reinstatement begins. Early consultation with an ethics attorney can help you make the right decision.

Reinstatement is not easy. Under current rules, an attorney has to wait five years from the date of the disbarment or effective date of the resignation to apply for reinstatement. To be reinstated, an attorney must prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that they have been rehabilitated from the misconduct that led to the disbarment or resignation; they must show must show passage of the Multi-state Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE); that they possess current learning and ability in the law; and that they possess current good moral character. The last requirement is the most difficult, requiring a demonstration of "sustained period of exemplary conduct." In addition, the attorney must reimburse the State Bar for all disciplinary costs and Client Security Fund payouts. Reinstatement petitions are almost always vigorously opposed by the State Bar, represented by lawyers from the Office of Chief Trial Counsel.

Reinstatement to practice is a major project not to be undertaken lightly. Reinstatement in most cases requires a minimum of a year of planning and preparation before the petition is filed.

"Mini-Reinstatement"

Attorneys, who are actually suspended from practice for two years or more, are typically required to establish their rehabilitation and current learning and ability in the law in a "mini-restatement" proceeding under Standard 1.4(c) (ii) of the Standards for Attorney Sanctions for Professional Misconduct.

This proceeding is less onerous than a full reinstatement. The burden of proof is a preponderance of evidence, not clear and convincing evidence, as in a full reinstatement.

David Cameron Carr provides experienced counsel and representation at reasonable rates.